Since enabling the launch of the first ETF over 30 years ago, the SEC has gradually but consistently relaxed regulations, enabling innovations like multiple ETF share classes, actively managed ETFs, and semi-transparent ETFs.Each time the SEC acts, a surge in innovation and assets has seemed to follow. In 2020, the SEC relaxed regulations yet again by issuing Rule 6c-11, allowing mutual funds to convert to ETFs without liquidation.
Asset managers such as PIMCO, JP Morgan, and BlackRock have already started to leverage this new rule, with many others likely to follow. Converting a fund to an ETF offers advantages such as lower expenses, better tax efficiency, increased liquidity, and the ability to maintain the mutual fund’s historical performance. However, conversion also presents challenges, requiring adjustments in fund accounting, custody, transfer agency, and fund administration and posing risks for tax efficiency and regulatory compliance. Understanding these challenges is crucial for a successful conversion.
Requirements for Custody
The role of custodians changes significantly when transitioning from mutual funds to ETFs. Unlike mutual funds, which often involve cash transactions, ETFs rely on in-kind transfers of securities through the creation and redemption process. This requires custodians to manage large-scale transactions between authorized participants (APs) and the fund, necessitating enhanced operational capabilities. They must ensure seamless processing of in-kind transfers, monitor daily portfolio changes, and maintain regulatory compliance. Asset managers should seek out custodians with systems that can handle the increased transaction volumes and ensure proper settlement and reconciliation.
The Benefits of Conversion over Launching a New Product
Maintaining Historical Performance - One of the primary reasons asset managers consider converting mutual funds to ETFs is the ability to retain the mutual fund’s historical performance. This track record can be an attractive feature for investors, particularly those seeking established funds with proven performance. In contrast, launching a new ETF from scratch would require time to build a track record, which can be a significant hurdle in attracting investors.
Removing Seed Capital - Converting a mutual fund to an ETF can be more cost-efficient than launching a new ETF. Running an ETF requires a minimum fund size to operate efficiently—generally at least $25 million in assets under management (AUM). However, for mutual funds that already have sufficient AUM, converting to an ETF can provide immediate scale and efficiency without the startup challenges.
Requirements for Fund Accounting
Converting a mutual fund to an ETF requires significant changes in valuation and reporting. Unlike mutual funds, which are priced once daily, ETFs are traded throughout the day, requiring real-time net asset value (NAV)calculations. This demands advanced technology for intraday pricing, more frequent reconciliations, and real-time portfolio snapshots. Additionally, ETFs' transparency requirements call for stricter data management to comply with SEC regulations and meet investor expectations. Utilizing a service provider with these capabilities, and developing the appropriate oversight and operational model, will be essential for successful conversions.
Requirements for Transfer Agency
Transfer agents have significantly reduced responsibilities in an ETF structure compared to a mutual fund. Since ETFs are exchange-traded, traditional shareholder recordkeeping is mostly eliminated. Instead, transfer agents focus on managing relationships with authorized participants (APs), overseeing ETF share settlements, and ensuring clear communication with the Depository Trust Company (DTC). They must also manage the operational details of creation and redemption baskets and handle ETF liquidity efficiently. This shift from direct shareholder services to an intermediary-focused model requires specialized systems and operational expertise.
Requirements for Fund Administration
For fund administrators, converting to ETFs introduces challenges in compliance, reporting, and risk management.ETFs require more frequent disclosure of portfolio holdings(often daily) and adherence to different liquidity and risk management standards. Administrators must update their compliance frameworks to meet these requirements and ensure that all operations, from performance measurement to regulatory filings, align with the ETF model. This often involves a thorough review and overhaul of existing procedures, systems, and policies to ensure smooth operations under the ETF structure.
Operational and Regulatory Challenges
Several key challenges must be addressed during the conversion process:
- Tax Efficiency: While in-kind redemptions make ETFs more tax-efficient than mutual funds, the transition must be carefully managed to prevent negative tax implications for existing shareholders.
- Technology Upgrades: Service providers, including custodians and transfer agents, may need to upgrade their systems to meet the unique operational requirements of ETFs.
- Regulatory Compliance: SEC Rule 6c-11 governs transparency and other ETF operations. These rules differ from the rules governing mutual funds. Asset managers must ensure that they and their service providers are familiar with—and able to meet—the regulatory requirements.
Despite the challenges, the increasing popularity of ETFs is expected to drive many mutual funds to transition to ETFs, either through direct conversions or more nuanced approaches.
Sign up to get industry insights delivered directly to your inbox
Conclusion
The decision to convert a mutual fund to an ETF—or to wait for ETF share class approval—is not one-size-fits-all. Each fund must evaluate its unique circumstances, including investor base, operational capacity, and strategic goals. What is clear is that ETF conversions represent a growing trend in the asset management industry, with over 70 conversions having taken place by mid-2024 alone.
Firms that can navigate the complex operational, regulatory, and compliance challenges will be well-positioned to capitalize on this shift. By partnering with an experienced consultant capable of supporting all aspects of the conversion process—from fund accounting to custody, transfer agency, and fund administration—asset managers can ensure a smooth transition and position themselves for long-term success in the ETF space.
